iVillage GardenWeb iVillage GardenWeb THE INTERNET'S GARDEN & HOME COMMUNITY ADVERTISEMENT
Blogs Forums Photo Galleries Ask The Experts Tools & Directories        
Return to the Quatre Gats Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Depression and the artist

Posted by CMcVay (My Page) on
Fri, Oct 10, 03 at 8:47

i am culling this from the "artists & sanity" thread, as it is a bit more specific. i feel that a lot of artistically minded people suffer from depression, for whatever reason, maybe in a disproportionate figure compared to other careers; not saying more than all, just a lot more than usual.

what have been, if any, your experiences with depression & its effects upon your art? does it handicap or inspire? how do you cope? how do you fail to cope? what do you think brings on the depression?, etc.

i will post my own experiences, but i want to see what others have to say first, just because i want to shape the thread as little as possible.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Depression and the artist

I guess there are numerous reasons for the woe to be an artist syndrome but I think a major one is that artists have to deal with failure more than most, either through their own self-appraisal or others criticism. It is often difficult to justify your own endeavors to yourself, let alone others. I once destroyed three years work because of a mini breakdown, which might have not been so bad if it wasn’t just before my degree show, ho hum, I’ll never get that lot back again…


 o
RE: Depression and the artist

I have always been easily stressed out, and have always felt sorta down. Its hard to explain to people not that I have ever mentioned this to anyone before. Some days ill be fine ill wake up and paint and other days ill wake up feeling suicidal but i paint anyway but constantly critize every brushstroke i make. I have destroyed artwork but never regretted it. im also an anorexic, And this is the first time i have ever confessed it to anyone. I dont want peoples attention I hate been in the spotlight to me it just doesnt feel right. i just like to paint and I am happy doing that forever, although back in june i went through a 3 month shutdown where i just could not even look at myself in the mirror never mind pick a brush up. I agree with the last persons point about critisism thats what happened to me back in june but Im back painting and i have learned i will not leave myself so vunrably open a second time. I have not had a bad childhood im 22 years of age and currently studying at uni. And ill carry on no matter how depressed i feel, for the simple reason of wanting to make my parents and two sisters proud of me. I feel that one day when i have acomlished this then i will be happy.

Then again I have had a number of people tell me that my artwork has been at its best when i have suffered greatly from depression.


 o
RE: Depression and the artist

after reading your post, cobain, i decided that this spoken word piece i did not too long ago would fit for now...i'll write a bit more about how it affects the art work later, the age thing just grabbed my eye & brought me back to this piece:

------------

ok, so here goes nothing. jack johnson plucks slow guitar strings while my heart sinks. the whole world is asleep besides me. i feel like the odd man out, a very odd man, i choose to be left out. i sleep too late, stay up too late, smoke too much. when i drink i get too drunk, when i read i'm lost in what i'm reading, when i create, i cease to exist.

i can't have just one girl, i have to have three. it's not even for sex, i need that many to keep up with me mentally. one for the stupid sh*t, the laughs and the reanimated childhood, one for the deep talks on the phone for four hours, one unattainable to keep my ego in check...actually, to keep me depressed. what fun would life be if i weren't in a funk? if i didn't garner the fuel to keep writing this junk.

things i should do plague me. it's 9:20, class starts in 5 minutes, shouldn't i get up? shouldn't i have gotten up 10 minutes ago? shouldn't i have gone to bed at 12 instead of 5am? shouldn't i have stayed home from the bar, stayed with my woman instead of riding around in the other girl's car looking for lost stars inside us? shouldn't i have slit my wrists when i was 15 and had the chance, had the recklessness and the abandon? shouldn't i have jumped...when i was 13? swam a bit further out so i couldn't swim back at age 10? shouldn't i just do it now?

there's no reason for all this. i have a pretty good life, i've come to terms with most of my demons, killed a few of them and made peace with the rest. but...there's always something. it's the one drop of cyanide that taints the entire water supply. it's that thing that in my happiest hour reminds me that it'll get worse...maybe it's the same thing that in my darkest hour lets me know that the best is yet to come. i dunno, it's kinda dumb. but sometimes i slip, and the world is against me again, they all want to isolate me and my only weapon is the pen.

i guess it's probably chemical...sorta like my roomate, except he has all sorts of chemicals to counteract his imbalance. me, i try to subjugate the rage and the sadness and the hopeless, masochistic self-chastising with will-power. with the passing of each hour i grow more tired, but i won't sleep. i will never sleep. i will never get up, get showered, get out to buy groceries, get out to breathe real oxygen, get out to interact and possibly save myself.

THIS IS A SUICIDE LETTER. but don't panic, i've been writing it for 22 years. i'll probably write it for 22 more, then 22 more after that. i'll probably die happy, old, with kids and grandkids who love and look up to me and will probably never know about the 7 circles of heaven and hell that wage war within me. so rest easy, i'll be here for a while. i'll just sit back and suffer being insane with my cigarrettes, girls and a smile.


 o
RE: Depression and the artist

For whatever its worth, CMcVay, you have a talent for writing.


 o
RE: Depression and the artist (and life in general)

hi, i'm new to this, so i'll kinda introduce myself. i'm a college student, an art major, and i found this forum through artchive, which has become one of my best friends on the internet. i've been wondering lately just why it seems that most of the greatest artists have such a tendency to kill themselves, either deliberately or indirectly through their alcohol-soaked and drugged-up lives. i still havent found the answer, but i think maybe its partially because artists are very deep emotionally, and they pour out these emotions into physical form. and when they're up, they're up in the clouds, and when they're down, they're in the depths of despair.

anyways, i was moved by what you wrote cmcvay. i understand how you feel. often i do not do what i want to do, and i do what i hate (procrastination anybody?)sometimes i just dont want to do all the things i have to do, i just want to stay in my bed and hide from the world and everything i have to do. but i always drag myself out of bed and muddle through, perhaps not with much of a smile on my face, but i always make it through. and i find that no matter how dismal everything looks, i simply can't give up the hope i carry inside me. this flickering light that refuses to go out. because hope never fails. i dont' do it through my own willpower, for i've found that i have no confidence in my own strength. i am so weak. i will always fail myself and others...so what hope do i have? "we rejoice in the hope of the glory of God. not only so, but we also rejoice in our sufferings, because we know that suffering produces perseverance; perseverance, character; and character, hope. and hope does not disappoint us, because God has poured out his love into our hearts by the Holy Spirit, whom He has given us." it goes on to say "you see, at just the right time, when we were still powerless, Christ died for the ungodly (i.e. everybody). very rarely will anyone die for a righteous man, though for a good man someone might possibly dare to die. but God demonstrates His own love fur us in this: while we were still sinners, Christ died for us". thats romans 5, theres a whole lot more good stuff in there... i dont know if you'll understand, heck i barely understand it myself. but thats how i survive, thats how i live. because there can be so much more to life than just surviving. and i've found that distracting myself with everything this world has to offer just doesnt satisfy me (see psalm 75:25-26).

as for needing 3 girls to keep you happy, i think thats pretty funny and also pretty silly. maybe you need to find some more multi-dimensional people. i know that personally i can laugh and be stupid, and have deep conversations, and i'm also unattainable. =)

anyways, i'm also obviously just another little jesus freak, perhaps a little sheltered, but not as sheltered as some might think. and it might seem that i went off on a little sermon, but i find it impossible to express what God has done in my life. but its the answer to the questions i keep seeing all around me, everyday.

i'm still wondering how to express all this in my artwork, but until i find my inspiration i'm kept busy with making pots and sculptures and other fun stuff. another thing i've noticed - it might be be the art that makes one crazy, because i know i've gotten a lot weirder since i've started taking serious art classes... i think it has something to do with all the sleep deprivation. but let me know what you think, even if you think i'm full of crap. =)


 o
RE: Depression and the artist

vawoodnyph, thank you. writing is the passion that shares my heart with the visual arts.

better watch out, the admin's banned religion & politics from the forums! lol...that's a ridiculous move in an art forum, as i've told him in an email. he didn't seem to read what i wrote tho, judging from his reply (i'll post both later).

to tell you the truth andi, 22 years of being the son of baptist missionaries has more than introduced me to this philosophy. in truth, it's probably numbed me to the message a bit. there are several reasons why i don't agree with it, but it wouldn't do either of us any good to have me rant about them here, and it would probably be kind of annoying to the others. i can email you about it if you want to talk about that tho.

i think some people will critisize you for stating your religious beliefs in here, since evangelic christianity isn't very popular these days. but you stated that you also are often depressed, and you have stated how you get through it, as i've asked, and i believe that is a valid response and your input would have been crippled without it.

the thing about three girls is artistic liscence at work...an exageration of the actual situation.

i don't think that most of the great artists do kill themselves. van gogh, pollock, basquiat & rothko are the only ones i can think of off the top of my head. a lot of the other greats died of old age, disease, or thru no fault of their own. this has been mentioned in here at some point, i believe...maybe by kim? it's what people want to believe because they want the idea that artists are crazy, self-destructive forces that blow big through life & die young.

well, i'll get back to the how-it-affects-my-work thing later, i need to think about it a bit more.


 o
RE: Depression and the artist

well i was unaware that politics and religion were taboo on here, (maybe i missed some terms of agreement or something) but i agree that its silly to say those arent allowed to be discussed when so much art is about religion and politics in the first place. and i know its not popular, but honestly i dont really care, and hey, the beauty of the internet is that people can express their feelings with complete anonymity, so its actually a pretty safe risk on my part. i'm sure people have been offended by a lot worse and its probably nothing new anyways. you are a pretty decent writer and if you like jack johnson you cant be all that bad, so sure, feel free to rant all you want about the failures of religion, my email is andijoy10@yahoo.com.

as for the artist being a stereotypical manic-depressive, i agree that not as many artists as most people think have killed themselves - in fact all the ones you listed were the ones i was thinking of. i have a professor who likes to enthrall us all with mulptiple tellings of rothko's bloody end, and i watched that basquiat film not too long ago, so thats probably why i've become more aware of these trends of depression and substance abuse in artists.

but it does make me sad to wonder what more van gogh could have done if he had painted for many more years...


 o
RE: Depression and the artist

Many of you may already be familiar with this book, but in case some of you have missed it, I highly recommend it, "Art & Fear" by David Bayles and Ted Orland. I'm no psychologist, so I won't attempt to diagnose clinical depression, but if your depression stems from the daily obstacles of being an artist, this book may help. Here's a brief synopsis.

"This is a book about the way art gets made, the reasons it often doesn't get made, and about the difficulties that cause so many artists to give up along the way. David Bayles and I are both working artists, grappling daily with the problems of making art in the real world. The observations we make are drawn from personal experience, and relate more to the needs of fellow artists than to the interests of viewers.

Do not mistake Art & Fear for a pop psychology self-help book -- we're not interested in freeing your inner child! This is a book about what it feels like to sit down at your potter's wheel or keyboard, easel or camera, trying to do the work you need to do. Simply put, you have a choice between giving your art your best shot and risking that it will not make you happy, or not giving it your best shot and thereby guaranteeing that it will not make you happy. What we have tried to do is illuminate the obstacles you face, and offer some artistic strategies for getting past them".


 o
RE: Depression and the artist

Much of the idea of the depressed artist is a stereotype that can be linked back to at least the times of Raphael. Back in those days it was believed that Mellon Collie carried with it aspects of creativity. Mellon Collie as an atribute became linked to certain colours and soon artists found that the public would believe in the art if the artist was indeed shown to be mellon collic.

The idea of personality traits being associated with creative jobs is still strong today. Rap artists are hardened street wise thugs. Physicits have the stereo type of being eccentric absent minded proffessors. Artists are shown to be depressive, isolated, eccentric, and passionate.

What I think is interesting is that as artists, our stereotype seems to bear a lot of truth. Many of my friends at school embody these characteristics and many of them sufffer from various forms of depression. I have been hospitalized for depression myself.

From my own personal experiences, I think that depression brings a certain need for introspection. To deal with depression we have to spend a lot of time and energy looking at ourselves, looking at the events and circumstances in our lives, and looking at the other people around us. If you do not learn these skills for yourself then depression will kill you.

But the kicker is this: All of the soul searching and observation and questioning takes you on a bit of journey, at the end of which, you will have a story to tell. These stories and ideas we find like this are incredible things to express. And the skills we develop with our depression gives us the ability to express them in more complex ways than "Hey man, my girl friend dumped me... f*$&%ing b*$^@"

In my opinon, artists don't get depressed. The depressed become artists. (obviously there's a lot of room in my theory for exceptions)


 o
the colour thing

oh, I forgot to explain the colour thing. Purple became associated with mellon collie. Artists would wear purple to show the public that they are mellon collic and therefor naturally creative. Raphael has that famous self portrait with him dressed all in purple.

I had an art history prof who linked this theory all the way up to batman.


 o
RE: Depression and the artist

I'm an illustrator working for over 15 years professionally and for me depression is to do with falling short of your own artistic criteria. Imagination is a blessing and a curse, I often feel dissatisfied with the work I produce and if I'm not being creative or productive, just looking at another artists work can fill me with envy and self-loathing. I deal with this through exercise and sex. People will warn you about sex addiction etc. etc. but it enhances my mood, my health (I only practise safe sex) and it's a nice contrast to the mental angst my work brings me. If I wasn't doing it then I'd be eating chocolate at home so i dont beat myself up about it. Yoga is also great.Learn to dance with your artistic side and keep a respectful distance when things get dark (I go to the movies). Remember you are not god just someone who can draw!


 
 

 

 


Click here to learn more about in-text links on this page.



iVillage GardenWeb: The Internet's Garden & Home Community  
  iVillage Home & Garden Network